Sixyard logo

New York City II vs Columbus Crew II: MLS Next Pro Match Preview

Players celebrating a goal during MLS Next Pro match
PredictionMLS Next Pro

New York City II welcome Columbus Crew II to Belson Stadium in an MLS Next Pro group-stage fixture where the underlying data slightly tilts the balance towards the hosts, despite Columbus sitting higher in the table. Standings show New York City II on 15 points from 10 matches (5-0-5, goal difference -3, goals 13-16) and Columbus Crew II on 20 points from 12 matches (7-0-5, goal difference 0, goals 20-20). However, the prediction model rates the home side as marginally stronger in this specific matchup.

Form-wise, both teams are volatile, but New York City II have the sharper recent edge. Their last-five form is graded at 60%, with attacking output at 48% and defensive performance at 62%, scoring 10 and conceding 8 across those five. Columbus Crew II come in with 40% form, attack at 43% and defence at 48%, scoring 9 and conceding 11 in their last five. Over a broader 10–12 game sample, Columbus have the better overall record (7 wins from 12 versus 5 from 10), but the model’s comparison metrics favour New York City II: 60% vs 40% in form, 53% vs 47% in attack, and 58% vs 42% in defence. The Poisson-based distribution also leans 57% towards the hosts versus 43% for the visitors.

Home/away splits are key for betting here. New York City II are strong at Belson Stadium in 2026 league play: 4 wins and 1 loss from 5 home matches, with 7 goals scored and 8 conceded. Columbus Crew II are much less convincing on the road, with 2 wins and 4 losses from 6 away fixtures, scoring 8 but conceding 14. That away defensive record (2.3 goals conceded on average) is a major red flag for backing an outright away win, especially against a side whose home attack averages 1.6 goals per match and tends to grow into games, with a high concentration of goals between minutes 46–75.

Head-to-Head Data

Head-to-head data in MLS Next Pro underlines how finely balanced this rivalry is, but also shows how often New York City II compete strongly at home. The indexed H2H list from the JSON is:

  • 2026-03-08 at Historic Crew Stadium (MLS Next Pro, Group Stage): Columbus Crew II 0–0 New York City II, Columbus declared winners after a 5–4 penalty shootout.
  • 2025-08-22 at Belson Stadium (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 31): New York City II 3–1 Columbus Crew II.
  • 2025-06-12 at Historic Crew Stadium (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 17): Columbus Crew II 1–1 New York City II, Columbus winning 5–4 on penalties.
  • 2025-03-14 at Belson Stadium (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 2): New York City II 2–0 Columbus Crew II.
  • 2024-09-01 at Historic Crew Stadium (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 34): Columbus Crew II 2–2 New York City II, Columbus winning 4–2 on penalties.
  • 2024-08-03 at Belson Stadium (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 24): New York City II 3–4 Columbus Crew II.
  • 2024-04-21 at Historic Crew Stadium (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 7): Columbus Crew II 0–2 New York City II.
  • 2023-09-08 at Historic Crew Stadium (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 25): Columbus Crew II 2–5 New York City II.
  • 2023-06-18 at Belson Stadium at St John’s University (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 12): New York City II 2–3 Columbus Crew II.
  • 2022-08-07 at Lower.com Field (MLS Next Pro, Regular Season - 17): Columbus Crew II 3–0 New York City II.

These fixtures show that matches at Belson Stadium are often open: scorelines of 3–1, 2–0, 3–4 and 2–3 indicate both teams usually find the net and games rarely finish level in regular time. Columbus have edged some high-scoring away wins there, but New York City II have also produced convincing home victories.

Prediction Model

The official prediction model is clear: it assigns New York City II a 45% win probability, a 45% chance of a draw and only 10% for a Columbus Crew II win. Overall comparison totals rate the hosts at 55.8% versus 44.2% for the visitors. The advice is explicitly: “Double chance : New York City II or draw,” supported by the combination of strong home form, Columbus’s weak away defence, and the balanced but high-variance H2H history.

Betting verdict: the data-driven play is to follow the model and back New York City II on the double chance market (home or draw). With Columbus still carrying offensive threat but leaking goals away, a cautious secondary angle would be to expect both teams to score, but the core value according to the official prediction is firmly on New York City II avoiding defeat rather than chasing an away upset.

Related News