Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers in History

The Premier League has showcased many players known for their calmness and accuracy when taking penalties. Leading this list is Alan Shearer with 56 successful spot-kick goals, closely followed by Yaya Touré, who holds a flawless penalty record. Other notable names include Matt Le Tissier and Harry Kane, both famous for their consistency. Emerging talents such as Cole Palmer and Erling Haaland continue to uphold the tradition of excellence from the penalty spot.

Penalties remain one of the most dependable scoring methods in football. Many forwards have relied heavily on their ability to score from these set-pieces. Over the years, only a few players have shown the nerve and precision needed to convert penalties consistently, especially in a high-pressure environment like the Premier League.

Here is a ranking based on penalty goals scored in the Premier League:

• Rank 10: Bukayo Saka – Arsenal (2019–Present) – 12 penalties scored
• Rank 9: James Beattie – Southampton, Everton, Sheffield United, Stoke City (1998–2010) – 16 penalties scored
• Rank 8: Callum Wilson – Bournemouth, Newcastle United (2014–Present) – 16 penalties scored
• Rank 7: Erling Haaland – Manchester City (2022–Present) – 20 penalties scored
• Rank 6: Danny Murphy – Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, Fulham (1997–2013) – 18 penalties scored
• Rank 5: Harry Kane – Tottenham Hotspur (2012–2023) – 33 penalties scored
• Rank 4: Cole Palmer – Manchester City, Chelsea (2021–Present) – 18 penalties scored
• Rank 3: Matt Le Tissier – Southampton (1992–2002) – 25 penalties scored
• Rank 2: Yaya Touré – Manchester City (2010–2018) – 11 penalties scored
• Rank 1: Alan Shearer – Blackburn Rovers, Newcastle United (1992–2006) – 56 penalties scored

Profiles of Premier League’s Best Penalty Takers

10. Bukayo Saka (Arsenal)

After a tough miss in the UEFA Euro 2020 final, Bukayo Saka quickly established himself as one of Arsenal's most reliable penalty takers. With a 92% conversion rate (12 out of 13), he shows remarkable composure for a young player.

• Appearances: 223
• Goals: 59
• Penalties Scored: 12
• Conversion Rate: 92%

9. James Beattie

James Beattie displayed great accuracy during his Premier League career across several clubs. He scored 16 penalties in 17 attempts, missing only once in 2006 without costing his team the match.

• Appearances: 270
• Goals: 90
• Penalties Scored: 16
• Conversion Rate: 94%

8. Callum Wilson

Callum Wilson has maintained an impressive penalty record since his time at Bournemouth. Known for his calmness, he converted 16 out of 17 penalties in the Premier League, showing reliability for every club he's represented.

• Appearances: 267
• Goals: 94
• Penalties Scored: 16
• Conversion Rate: 94%

7. Erling Haaland (Manchester City)

The prolific striker Erling Haaland has been nearly unstoppable from the penalty spot, netting 20 goals from 23 attempts. His sharp instincts and clinical finishing contribute significantly to his team's success.

• Appearances: 129
• Goals: 109
• Penalties Scored: 20
• Conversion Rate: 87%

6. Danny Murphy

Danny Murphy was highly respected for his penalty prowess during his time at clubs like Liverpool and Fulham. He missed just one penalty in over 400 appearances, ending with an impressive 95% success rate.

• Appearances: 417
• Goals: 66
• Penalties Scored: 18
• Conversion Rate: 95%

5. Harry Kane

Harry Kane is among the top scorers from the spot, with 33 penalties converted out of 37 attempts during his Premier League career at Tottenham. Despite a slightly lower 89% conversion rate, his consistency remains noteworthy.

• Appearances: 320
• Goals: 213
• Penalties Scored: 33
• Conversion Rate: 89%

4. Cole Palmer

Cole Palmer had an almost perfect penalty record until recently, scoring 18 of 19 spot kicks. His cool-headed approach continues to impress fans and coaches alike.

• Appearances: 111
• Goals: 46
• Penalties Scored: 18
• Conversion Rate: 95%

3. Matt Le Tissier

Known as "Le God," Matt Le Tissier is one of the most legendary penalty takers. He converted 24 out of 25 penalties with Southampton, showcasing his precise shooting skills.

• Appearances: 270
• Goals: 101
• Penalties Scored: 24
• Conversion Rate: 96%

2. Yaya Touré

Yaya Touré holds the rare distinction of never missing a Premier League penalty. During his spell with Manchester City, he scored all 11 penalties he took, making him a standout midfielder with exceptional composure.

• Appearances: 230
• Goals: 62
• Penalties Scored: 11
• Conversion Rate: 100%

1. Alan Shearer

Topping the list is Alan Shearer, the Premier League's all-time leading scorer. Although he missed over 10 penalties, his 56 successful spot-kick goals remain unmatched, reflecting his coolness under pressure and lethal finishing.

• Appearances: 441
• Goals: 260
• Penalties Scored: 56
• Conversion Rate: 84%

Frequently Asked Questions

• Who is the Premier League's greatest penalty taker?Alan Shearer leads the list with the highest number of penalties scored.
• Is Erling Haaland among the top 10 Premier League penalty takers?Yes, he ranks seventh on the list.
• Who are the top three Premier League penalty takers?Alan Shearer, Yaya Touré, and Matt Le Tissier.
• Where does Erling Haaland stand among EPL penalty takers?He is seventh on the all-time list.