New York City II vs FC Cincinnati II Prediction: Preview and Betting Tips

New York City II welcome FC Cincinnati II to Belson Stadium in MLS Next Pro Group Stage action on 23 May 2026. With both sides in the Northeast Division looking to climb the overall Eastern Conference picture, this fixture has the feel of an early-season six-pointer rather than a routine group game.

New York City II sit on 12 points from 9 matches, while FC Cincinnati II trail with 9 points from 10 games. The hosts have been strong at Belson Stadium, winning three of their four home outings, whereas Cincinnati’s away form has been a major concern with five defeats from five on the road. Stats suggest this is a prime opportunity for New York City II to consolidate their position and for FC Cincinnati II to try to halt a worrying travel trend.

Analysis points to a tight encounter: predictive metrics give New York City II and the draw equal weight, with FC Cincinnati II clear outsiders. Yet the head-to-head history between these MLS Next Pro second teams has often been dramatic, with several high-scoring clashes and penalty shootouts. That blend of current form and historic rivalry makes this one of the more intriguing MLS Next Pro predictions on the card.

New York City II vs FC Cincinnati II Key Stats

• New York City II have 12 points from 9 matches (4 wins, 5 losses, 0 draws) with 11 goals scored and 16 conceded in league play.
• Across their last five MLS Next Pro meetings listed, New York City II have three wins in regulation time against FC Cincinnati II, while Cincinnati have one outright win and one penalty shootout success.
• FC Cincinnati II concede an average of 2.4 goals per game away from home this season, with 12 goals shipped in 5 away fixtures.

New York City II vs FC Cincinnati II — Tale of the Tape

• Position: 6 vs 7 (Northeast Division)
• Points: 12 vs 9
• Goals For: 11 vs 12
• Goals Against: 16 vs 19
• Clean Sheets: New York City II 0 vs FC Cincinnati II 2

In the Northeast Division standings, New York City II hold sixth place with 12 points and a -5 goal difference from 9 matches. Their record of 4 wins and 5 defeats, with no draws, underlines a high-variance side capable of both strong performances and heavy setbacks. FC Cincinnati II are just behind in seventh, on 9 points from 10 games, also with a negative goal difference of -7 after 12 scored and 19 conceded.

Home and away splits sharpen the picture. New York City II have taken 9 of their 12 points at home, winning 3 of 4 at Belson Stadium, while FC Cincinnati II have lost all 5 of their away fixtures, scoring just 2 and conceding 12. Season records back New York City II as the more balanced side, with slightly better attacking output per game and similar defensive frailties, but Cincinnati’s extreme home/away contrast suggests they are a very different proposition on the road.

New York City II vs FC Cincinnati II Key Matchups

Attacking Units vs Fragile Defences

Without individual scoring and assist data, the collective numbers tell the story. New York City II average 1.3 goals per match across 9 fixtures, while conceding 1.9. FC Cincinnati II are close in attack with 1.2 goals per game, but again leak 1.9 on average. At home, New York City II’s attack rises to 1.5 goals per game, and FC Cincinnati II’s defence worsens away, allowing 2.4 per match.

This matchup of relatively efficient forward lines against vulnerable back lines points toward a contest where both sides create chances. New York City II’s biggest home defeat of 0-5 shows their defensive ceiling can collapse, but Cincinnati’s away run of five straight losses, including a 4-0 reverse as their heaviest away defeat, indicates their back line is under greater pressure when travelling.

Set-Piece and Discipline Battle

Discipline and defensive concentration could be decisive. New York City II have accumulated yellow cards heavily in the 16–30 and 76–90 minute ranges, with 6 bookings in each window, plus a red card between 76–90 minutes. FC Cincinnati II also see a spread of cautions, with notable spikes early (5 yellows in 0–15 minutes) and around the hour mark (5 yellows in 46–60 minutes), as well as a red card late in games (76–90 minutes).

With both teams prone to late cards and defensive lapses between 61–90 minutes, the closing stages could open up. Any value in live betting may come from anticipating late goals or bookings once fatigue and game state start to bite.

Head-to-Head: Last Meetings

This has been a lively series in MLS Next Pro, with a mix of clear wins and penalty-decided draws. Across the nine listed meetings, both clubs have enjoyed strong spells, and several encounters have produced at least three goals in regulation time.

• 13 April 2026: FC Cincinnati II 1-0 New York City II (MLS Next Pro Group Stage)
• 6 July 2025: FC Cincinnati II 2-2 New York City II (MLS Next Pro Regular Season - 22, FC Cincinnati II won 5-4 on penalties)
• 9 April 2025: New York City II 2-2 FC Cincinnati II (MLS Next Pro Regular Season - 6, FC Cincinnati II won 5-3 on penalties)
• 30 September 2024: New York City II 3-1 FC Cincinnati II (MLS Next Pro Regular Season - 40)
• 7 July 2024: FC Cincinnati II 1-1 New York City II (MLS Next Pro Regular Season - 23, New York City II won 4-3 on penalties)
• 27 August 2023: FC Cincinnati II 2-0 New York City II (MLS Next Pro)
• 28 May 2023: New York City II 2-1 FC Cincinnati II (MLS Next Pro)
• 14 September 2022: FC Cincinnati II 0-4 New York City II (MLS Next Pro)
• 2 July 2022: New York City II 5-1 FC Cincinnati II (MLS Next Pro)

New York City II vs FC Cincinnati II Prediction

Form and predictive metrics lean towards the hosts avoiding defeat. New York City II are given a 45% chance of victory and a 45% chance of a draw, with FC Cincinnati II rated at just 10% to win. That aligns neatly with the standings: New York City II have more points from fewer games and a strong home record, while FC Cincinnati II’s away form is winless and porous.

Head-to-head history does offer FC Cincinnati II some encouragement, particularly their recent penalty shootout successes and the 1-0 home win on 13 April 2026. However, those results came either at home or on neutral footing in terms of pressure. At Belson Stadium, New York City II have historically dominated, scoring 3, 2, 5 and 2 goals in four of the listed home meetings.

With both sides averaging around 1.2–1.3 goals for and 1.9 against per match, and with predictions favouring New York City II or the draw, the most likely pattern is the hosts controlling territory and chances, while FC Cincinnati II look to exploit transitions. Defensive frailties on both sides suggest opportunities, but Cincinnati’s away scoring rate of just 0.4 goals per game tempers expectations of an away breakthrough.

Predicted Score: New York City II 1-0 FC Cincinnati II

New York City II League Form

WLWLW

FC Cincinnati II League Form

LLWWL

New York City II Possible Starting Lineup

Goalkeepers: B. Klein, M. Learned, D. McDermott, T. Romero; Defenders: K. Acito, A. Baiera, A. Campos, Nico Cavallo, J. Lopez, E. Martin, Maxwell Murray, D. Randazzo, K. Smith; Midfielders: Jacob Arroyave, M. Carrizo, D. Duque, C. Flax, D. Kerr, P. Molinari, Musu, K. Pierre, J. Ponce, Arnau Rabassa, J. Shore, J. Suchecki, L. Sunjic, U. Zeitz, G. de Souza; Forwards: C. Danquah, L. De Pinho, A. Farnos, H. Hvatum, M. Jones, S. Reid, E. Samb.

New York City II have a deep squad across all lines, with multiple goalkeepers and a broad pool of defenders and midfielders to shape their approach at Belson Stadium. The absence of clean sheets this season suggests the back line is still a work in progress, but the variety of attacking options allows for flexible tactical setups, whether they opt for wide forwards or more central combinations.

FC Cincinnati II Possible Starting Lineup

Goalkeepers: L. Broz, C. Dale, B. Dowd, Fabian Mrozek, D. Paz; Defenders: A. Chirila, G. DeHart, D. Hurtado, A. Ibrahim, W. Kuisel, S. Lachekar, A. Lajhar, D. Lester, M. Miazga, Felix Samson; Midfielders: A. Chavez, N. Gassan, G. Granda, N. Gray, J. Mize, Y. Ramos, S. Sanchez, C. Sphire, M. Sullivan; Forwards: Stefan Chirila, C. Holmes, G. Marioni, D. Mosquera, C. Niang, L. Orejarena, R. Schlotterbeck, M. Vazquez.

FC Cincinnati II’s squad mixes youth and experience, with several teenage defenders and attackers complemented by more seasoned figures. At home they have found a way to translate that into goals and clean sheets, but the away record indicates difficulties in maintaining structure under pressure. The coaching staff may lean on more experienced defenders and midfielders to try to stabilise performances on the road.

New York City II Team News

No significant absences reported.

FC Cincinnati II Team News

No significant absences reported.

Injuries & Suspensions

New York City II:

• None reported.

FC Cincinnati II:

• None reported.

Betting Tips: New York City II vs FC Cincinnati II

Exactly 3 distinct tips from different markets:

• Result Tip: Back New York City II in the double chance (home win or draw). Predictive percentages give the hosts a combined 90% chance of avoiding defeat (45% win, 45% draw) against just 10% for an away victory, reinforced by New York City II’s strong home record and FC Cincinnati II’s five straight away losses.
• Goals Tip: Under 2.5 goals. Both teams average 1.2–1.3 goals for and 1.9 against overall, but FC Cincinnati II’s away attack has produced only 2 goals in 5 matches (0.4 per game). That limited away threat, plus the conservative predicted 1-0 scoreline, supports a lower-scoring contest.
• Value Tip: New York City II to win to nil. The visitors have failed to score in 3 of their 5 away games this season and have yet to earn a single point on the road. Given New York City II’s home strength and the prediction edge in their favour, a home win without conceding offers an appealing higher-risk, higher-reward angle.

How to Watch New York City II vs FC Cincinnati II

Broadcast coverage varies by region. General guide:

• Spain: Movistar LaLiga
• UK: Premier Sports
• Australia: beIN Sports
• India: FanCode
• MENA: beIN Sports
• South America: ESPN / Disney+
• Africa: SuperSport

Odds are accurate at the time of writing and subject to change. Please gamble responsibly.